So first off: Rimworld is life. I’m over 4000 hours now. If Royalty was released as a button that said, “Ludeon needs 20 bucks” I would have pushed it. I’m zero percent upset about it.
But if it can be improved upon, I want to contribute. And I figured out what I dislike pretty fast, and I’ve seen the same sentiment from a lot of others. And it’s this:
It turns your colonists into assholes.
Any colonist who gets a title starts slowly become an obnoxious piece of shit. I don’t want to give titles to that one colonist I already find annoying. I want my favorite colonist(s) to be the leaders. But now I hate them. And I want to like my colony.
I honestly wonder if this can be addressed by simply changing some of the language in the game, and tweaking some of the events. This throne room bullshit, ‘undignified’ bedrooms, refusal to work, and royal decrees. I get it that you need to balance the psychic abilities, but there has to be a way to handle that in a way that doesn’t make you hate your own colonists.
I’m not sure what good alternatives are, but I’m sure the community could come up with some, and I’m looking forward to a nicely balanced ‘Colony Royals Aren’t Twats’ mod
/soapbox
Edit: a number of the responses have summarized the issue better than I did: Rimworld is a story generator, and having your survivalist pawns rapidly degenerate into selfish, entitled assholes is bad storytelling. A ton of this is just a narrative problem, not necessarily a mechanics problem.