I’ll provide more feedback once I’ve played more, but initial impressions are also important in my opinion. So after about 40 minutes of gameplay, my overall reaction is pretty negative. I think it boils down to 2 main things:
1 – So much of the gameplay is just movement. Now the movement that has been implemented is impressive from a technical standpoint sure. But the problem is that movement is boring. Early game accounts spend so much of their time unlocking teleports or levelling agility for the express purpose of avoiding having to run anywhere. So when a new skill is built around the fundamental concept of moving around… well, I’m already starting to wonder where my teleports are I guess.
2 – Sailing feels detached from the rest of the world, and is almost like it’s own game. This may change as more content is added, but I feel like sailing is currently ‘osrs, but on a boat!’, and not an integrated part of the game. Every other skill has locations all across the world, and are often a part of the natural environment and ecosystems. They all overlap constantly with every other piece of content. Sailing is, by its very nature, in a completely separate location to the rest of the game. So on land you have OSRS, and on water you have OSRS: Sailing. I don’t know if this is a problem that will go away once you add more skills and content and once I get used to it more, or if its just a fundamental problem with the skill overall. But I’m again feeling quickly like I want to get back to playing the ‘real game’.
From a technical standpoint the skill is fine so far. Movement is smooth, it’s pretty obvious what you need to do, the new locations seem good etc. I can also see plenty of potential in the quests and in the environment for future development. But I’m so far struggling to overcome these more fundamental issues right now.
Again, this is feedback after about 40 minutes of gameplay. It may be in 2-3 hours it’s all changed. I just don’t want to dismiss these early feelings either. I'm really not trying to just shit all over a new idea - I'm just trying to understand where my initial reactions are coming from.